Grower won't recall sprouts; FDA, CDC weigh in - The Packer

Grower won't recall sprouts; FDA, CDC weigh in

06/28/2011 10:42:00 AM
Coral Beach

Although the Food and Drug Administration issued a warning to consumers June 27 to not eat alfalfa sprouts from Evergreen Produce because of possible salmonella contamination, the owner of the company declined to recall her product until the agency could provide “hard evidence.”

The Idaho Department of Health & Welfare is investigating a number of cases believed to be connected to the consumption of alfalfa sprouts, according to the FDA.

Nadine Scharf owns 23-year-old Evergreen Produce Inc., Moyie, Idaho. She said June 27 that someone reported to health officials that they had gotten sick after eating Evergreen sprouts in recent weeks, but that there haven’t been any new illnesses reported since June 2.

“The FDA encouraged us to do a recall but I said I needed to see hard evidence that our sprouts were involved,” Scharf said. “They are down to only three cases now. It started out that they thought 20 people were sick, then they dropped that number to six and now it’s down to three. And they say it will be a week before any tests results will be available.”

In a June 27 news release, FDA officials pointed out that the possible salmonella contamination is not the same strain as was responsible for dozens of deaths and thousands of illnesses in Europe.

Charles Breen, the FDA district director in Bothell, Wash., confirmed June 27 that the agency had taken swab samples at Evergreen Produce, but he declined to provide any other details.

“This is an open investigation,” Breen said, adding that he did not know how long the investigation would take. “It depends on where the evidence leads us.”

Emily Simnitt, public information officer for the Idaho Health and Welfare Department, said three confirmed cases of salmonella had been logged in Idaho in recent weeks, but that no new cases had been reported as of June 27. She said one of the three sick people reported eating Evergreen Produce brand sprouts, but she declined further comment.

Details from the FDA’s main office were not too specific, either.

“I unfortunately can’t share details about FDA’s investigation other than what’s been made public in the press release,” said FDA public affairs spokeswoman Stephanie Yao.

Although the agency has the power under the new Food Safety Modernization Act to mandate a recall, it had not done so as of June 28.

Prev 1 2 Next All

Comments (4) Leave a comment 

e-Mail (required)


characters left

Texas  |  June, 28, 2011 at 02:41 PM

Good for you girl. There needs to be more of this. If these type of maybes continues there are going to be a lot of broke companies in the produce industry.

US  |  June, 28, 2011 at 02:54 PM

This is just the type of hype the FDA likes to pour out in hopes of shutting down the small farmers and growers. Get everyone scared, promise them protection with more government oversight and Big Gov gets bigger. Thank you for standing up to the FDA!

Nick Naranja    
Sunshine State  |  June, 29, 2011 at 10:43 AM

It costs an awful lot of money to do a recall, and to do so without actually having evidence of being the culprit is a really bad way to go broke. I think the FDA should be required to cut you a check for the entire costs of the recall and lost sales if it turns out that nothing was wrong.

US  |  June, 29, 2011 at 11:55 AM

It should only take 18-24 hours to culture salmonella. A quick test which would not leave a producer in a lerch if FDA were truly interested in doing the right thing.

Feedback Form
Leads to Insight