Poll: Should the USDA approve the GMO Arctic apple? - The Packer

Poll: Should the USDA approve the GMO Arctic apple?

09/04/2012 06:30:00 AM
Tom Karst

National Editor Tom KarstThe federal docket where the USDA is taking comments on the deregulation of the Arctic GMO apple continues to draw heavy traffic.  With the comment period ending Sept. 11, there are well over 1,100 comments on the petition to deregulate.

Most comments are running negative, similar to this comment:

I am a consumer and a concerned parent. I am writing to urge you not to approve Okanagan Specialty Fruit's petition for deregulation of its nonbrowning "Arctic" apple.

The manipulation of such a commonly grown fruit could cause contamination of nearby organic or conventional apple orchards, and unlabeled GMO apples could find their way into non-GMO fruit slices and juice at the processing level. Also, the Arctic apple's nonbrowning appearance could mask the age of apples and mislead consumers into thinking that GMO apples are fresher than they really are.

The U.S. Apple Association and grower groups already have voiced their disapproval of these GMO apples due to the negative impact they could have on the non-GMO apple industry. And without a label, consumers may unknowingly purchase and consume Arctic apples.

This product is unnecessary and poses several risks to the apple industry and consumers in exchange for a fix to a minor aesthetic flaw. In its environmental review, USDA should choose the no action alternative and not approve this GMO apple variety. Sincerely, Jackie Gerding


Yet, there are voices of support, like this example from Steve Savage,  that urge the USDA to approve the variety:

To whom it may concern, I believe that the Arctic apples should definitely be approved. Many who have commented do not seem to realize that these apples will be explicitly labeled as biotech apples and their non-browning character will be advertised as such. Unlike grains, identity preservation is the norm in the apple industry and consumers pick specific varieties that suit their taste.

This will be no different. If someone does not want to eat them, they can simply buy other apples. Some may raise the issue of "genetic contamination." In the rare event that a bee moves from an Arctic apple block to another, the only thing in the resulting apples will be embryos in seeds.

Prev 1 2 Next All

Comments (1) Leave a comment 

e-Mail (required)


characters left

Frankfort, Mi  |  November, 12, 2013 at 07:36 AM

Yes, we can thank science for our biggest U.S. export - topsoil - and the dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico. Let's not let politics or scare-mongering trump the arrogance of what we don't know that we don't know.

Feedback Form
Leads to Insight