Innovation should be looked at with a healthy dose of skepticism

(Photo courtesy of LGMA)

In late 2022, Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes was sentenced to 11 years in jail for defrauding investors while running the failed blood testing startup. Holmes had convinced legions of supporters and investors including Henry Kissinger, Rupert Murdoch and the Walton family of Walmart fame that Theranos was going to be the next big thing in health care. She was featured on the cover of Time magazine, introduced by President Bill Clinton and featured as a great innovator. In her words, “… first they think you're crazy, then they fight you, then you change the world.”

What made Holmes so compelling? Her allure, and that of Theranos, represented the perfect cocktail for appeal — a combination of innovation and promise to help solve some of health care’s most pressing challenges. She was viewed as a young, female tech superstar exhibiting grit and vision worthy of admiration. Some of these traits also attracted investors to other companies such as Nicola, an American manufacturer of heavy-duty electric vehicles. 

The brainchild of Trevor Milton, an engaging, charismatic huckster, Nicola was once valued at more than $24 billion, more than Ford Motors. A former door-to-door alarm salesman, Milton convinced investors, including General Motors, to invest in the company. Like Theranos, Milton was later shown to have engaged in fraud in the positioning of his company. 

There are many other examples of great ideas poorly or never executed. Think FTX, Enron and Worldcom to name a few. These stories offer lessons for us in food and agriculture as well. 

Real and proposed innovations are taking place in our industry every day with potential for seismic shifts. Many of these innovations stem around solving challenges related to climate change, use of natural resources, labor and the environment. In fact, the potential to do good and drive positive change is what often attracts innovators — often outside of agriculture – to explore new ways to grow, process and bring to market food. When these ideas also seem to make a good business case for farmers, processors or marketers, they become even more compelling. 

While innovation and new technology should be supported, we also need to be mindful of individuals and companies that may overpromise and underdeliver. Sure, they may not quite cross the threshold as being fraudulent, but a healthy dose of skepticism is important to ensure investments are made in innovations with real potential. 

New projects supported by big-name tech giants are gaining traction and attracting supporters, including agricultural leaders and food brands. Silicon Valley continues to ideate new ways to solve what is often viewed as decades-old farming practices in need of a reboot. 

No doubt, robotics, sensors, artificial intelligence and more are exciting opportunities. Likewise, indoor farming and controlled environment agriculture hold promise. Promoted as a solution to food deserts, inner-city jobs, sustainability concerns, food safety, water usage and the demand for locally grown foods, controlled environment agriculture feels like a worthy investment. But — as we should with all investments — we should practice caution. 

As investors, we need to ask the tough questions about new technologies. We need to ask for results, analytics and proof points. We need to apply our own knowledge and expertise to the evaluation process. Depending on your risk tolerance, some investors should consider a wait-and-see approach, giving time for ideas to prove valuable — or not. In short, with new innovations, an old adage holds true: buyer beware.


Tim York is CEO of the California Leafy Green Marketing Agreement.
 
 

 

Latest News

How new research could prevent frost damage in orchards
How new research could prevent frost damage in orchards

In this podcast episode, Advanced Agriscience's Collin Juurakko shares interesting discoveries he's made about how frost crystals form and how that lead to a potential solution for tree-fruit growers across the globe.

Cool Creations previews new products at AWG show
Cool Creations previews new products at AWG show

North Kansas City, Mo.-based Cool Creations LLC had two new products to show off at the Associated Wholesale Grocers' seventh annual Innovation Showcase, March 25-26.

Dole, Fresh Express nix sale of fresh vegetables division
Dole, Fresh Express nix sale of fresh vegetables division

Following Department of Justice concerns about competition in the packaged salad market, the companies have abandoned the proposed $308 million deal.

Fresh Del Monte named to most trusted companies list
Fresh Del Monte named to most trusted companies list

Fresh Del Monte is among the honorees on the Most Trustworthy Companies in America 2024 list, recognized for a commitment to quality, sustainability and innovation in fresh produce.

Improved conditions for West Mexico produce may arrive with spring
Improved conditions for West Mexico produce may arrive with spring

West Mexico growers faced a tough fall/winter season, but distributors believe things are looking up for spring with increased supplies and more reasonable prices.

What’s next for retail foodservice: Retailers dish up insights in free webinar
What’s next for retail foodservice: Retailers dish up insights in free webinar

"Impact Retail Foodservice 2024" will gather industry experts to discuss opportunities and challenges, as well as share insights for driving growth in the year ahead in one of the hottest departments in grocery.