Following this year’s cyclospora outbreak, produce businesses and associations need to throw out the old crisis communications rulebook and create a new one, says Marilyn Freeman, owner of Farmers Communication Exchange, an agricultural public relations and association management firm.
“Somehow or other, whenever these things happen, we just don’t handle them very well,” she says.
The High Cost of Silence on Social Media
Part of that, she suspects, is the industry’s hesitancy to speak up. This could be for several reasons, including distrust of mainstream media and social media. So, when a food safety outbreak is traced or even potentially traced to fresh produce, organizations’ first instinct might be to remain quiet.
“People don’t understand agriculture and farming and how it works,” she says. “There’s a lot of misinformation that happens. It’s almost like it’s risky to say something and be misquoted or say something and say the wrong thing.”
This, she says, is a big problem. As seen in how misinformation spread on social media this summer, Freeman cautions organizations that not communicating can backfire.
“We’re starting to see a risk of not talking,” she says. “It is becoming a bigger and bigger problem, particularly with social media.”
She points to many produce industry insiders who emphasize the need for a crisis communications plan; while that’s good to have, she says it’s most important to use it.
“You need to employ what’s in your crisis plan,” she says. “You just do.”
Modernizing the Crisis Playbook Beyond Traditional Media
This includes using social media. She says crisis communication used to be simple: taking out a full-page ad in The New York Times. But in many ways, crisis communication has become more sophisticated and simplified at the same time.
“Most companies, most associations have social media now, and they’re already engaging in it,” she says. “They’ve actually got a mechanism to communicate.”
While there may be several avenues in which to get your message out, she says there are more mediums that an organization or company can tap into to get the message across.
“We can show video, we can talk to growers, we can educate people through these channels,” she says. “When there’s a food safety crisis, this is the only time that consumers are paying attention to what you are doing. It’s your opportunity now to speak.”
Tap into scientific experts, too, Freeman says, acknowledging those experts are already likely part of a crisis plan and can help communicate and explain the science behind the outbreak.
“Let’s say you’re an industry and you have a big problem and then all of a sudden your social media goes silent,” she says. “What does that tell consumers?”
Turning a Crisis Into a Food Safety Education Opportunity
While reviewing how the 2026 cyclospora outbreak unfolded, it’s easy to blame federal agencies and other state health agencies, but Freeman says, “I don’t think it was the best-handled situation.”
She makes a big distinction between crisis communication for a company potentially linked to an outbreak versus an association that represents a category.
While organizations hesitate to single out a specific growing region or commodity that may be under the microscope of an outbreak, she says there are ways to communicate and isolate a particular commodity or area that can help consumers who are hungry for information.
“That lets people know what they should be concerned about and what they don’t need to be concerned about,” she says.
In the early days of a food safety outbreak, Freeman says, communicate with empathy and concern, indicating the industry is following the outbreak closely.
“I always recommend whatever the FDA [Food and Drug Administration] or CDC [Centers for Disease Control and Prevention] is saying about what consumers should do; don’t disagree with them,” she says. “You have to agree with whatever the agency is telling consumers to do. … Do follow the advice of the health agencies.”
This is where the industry’s inclination to not speak up has to stop, she says. It’s easy to not want to misspeak, but the industry desperately needs leadership from associations at that critical moment.
“If you truly want to use this opportunity to educate people about the safety of your product, engaging early establishes you as a source of information that people can look to,” she says. “Take every opportunity that you can to educate people about things that happen in your industry to prevent foodborne illness.”
Freeman says to use the opportunity to explain what food safety processes are already in place to help assure consumers of produce safety. This includes traceback activities, water testing, etc. — everything a produce business already does. These are key places where consumers want to know more, and it’s going to make them feel better about the produce they buy.
“We know all of the things that the produce industry is doing to make sure this doesn’t happen and people don’t know it,” she says.
This is where social media is a particularly good medium to deploy, as an organization can show consumers what they’re doing. Find a good grower spokesperson who is comfortable on camera to help explain water testing, traceback and other farming practices that will help consumers understand the outbreak and food safety better.
“You can get out in the field, and you can film it,” she says.
The Role of Trade Associations vs. Individual Companies
Freeman says the most important part of a crisis response is being prepared.
“Know what your story is about and specifically what you’re doing for food safety,” she says. “You should be ready to tell that story.”
Assemble credible third-party experts such as nutritionists and researchers to help share all the work the industry does to prevent food safety outbreaks.
Of course, she says if an organization or produce business doesn’t have a communications consultant on staff, it’s important to work with one during an outbreak. This consultant can help decide when it is the right time to say something — or not say something — and how to say it.
“I regularly prepare pages and pages of potential answers to tough questions that will come up,” she says, noting that things may shift as an outbreak unfolds, but all that preparation is important.
This content can be prepared ahead of time and be pre-approved by leadership or a board of directors so there isn’t a lag if a crisis does hit.
“You’re really just educating people about what you do every day,” she says.